Halloween Costume ideas 2015
MPS
Latest Post


Dalam kehangatan porak peranda isu bantahan pelaksanaan GST dan demonstrasi ‪#‎kitalawan‬ serta tangkapan polis terhadap para aktivis dan demonstran, isu yang berlarutan hampir tiga tahun ini tenggelam.
Timbalan Presiden PAS, Mat Sabu dihadapkan ke Mahkamah Sesyen Butterworth atas dakwaan fitnah Bukit Kepong.
Peristiwa Bukit Kepong dirakamkan dalam sebuah filem nukilan Jins Shamsudin (orang Taiping). Dalam filem tersebut digambarkan perjuangan "polis melayu" melawan "pengganas komunis".
Sebaliknya menurut Mat Sabu, Mat Indera, watak sejarah yang mengepalai serangan ke atas balai polis/ rumah pasung tersebut diangkat oleh Mat Sabu sebagai wira manakala pihak polis adalah pengkhianat bangsa. Pendiriannya ini disokong dengan tulisan dan penerbitan buku sejarah Pengukir Nama Johor terbitan Yayasan Warisan Johor yang memasukkan Mat Infera sebagai salah seorang wira anak Johor.
Saksi terakhir daripada 11 orang saksi yang dipanggil oleh pihak pendakwa adalah Prof. Emeritus Dr. Khoo Kay Kim, guru sejarah saya sewaktu menuntut di universiti. Prof Khoo memberikan kenyataan beliau pada 27 Mac yang lalu.
Mat Sabu dituduh mengeluarkan kenyataan kontroversi tentang kejadian Bukit Kepong yang berlaku tujuh tahun sebelum pengisytiharan kemerdekaan Tanah Melayu dalam ceramah beliau di Bukit Gelugor pada bulan Ogos 2011.
Kenyataan beliau dalam ceramahnya itu telah meletuskan polemik nasional tentang status Mat Indera yang mengetuai serangan ke atas balai polis atau rumah pasung Bukit Kepong di Johor sebagai pejuang atau pengkhianat.
Dengan tidak semena-mena, kenyataan bahawa "Malaysia tidak pernah dijajah" dikeluarkan oleh Majlis Professor Negara (MPN) di bawah sebuah kluster pimpinan Prof. Zainal Kling. Kenyataan ini mencetuskan polemik baharu pula dalam negara.
Saya pernah berdiskusi secara bersemuka dengan Prof Khoo bertanyakan tentang isu ini.
Pandangan beliau tentang "Malaysia tidak Pernah Dijajah" adalah pandangan asli beliau, yang kemudiaannya diangkat oleh Majlis Professor Negara di bawah kluster pimpinan Zainal Kling.
PKPIM ada menemplak pandangan MPN pada September 2013:http://www2.bharian.com.my/…/TafsiranMPNmengenaiBri…/Article
Menurut beliau, Malaysia tak pernah dijajah kerana "last say" adalah terletak pada Raja-raja Melayu, bukan kerajaan British. Malah, bayi yang lahir di Tanah Melayu adalah rakyat Tanah Melayu, bukan rakyat British sepertimana lazimnya berlaku kpd tanah jajahan British yg lain. Sebagai contoh, bayi yang lahir di Strait Settlement (Melaka, Penang dan Singapura) adalah warga British kerana strait settlement diletakkan langsung di bawah Colonial Office di London.
Secara perundangan, Tanah Melayu dikategorikan sbg negara lindungan (protectorate state), bukan negara jajahan.
Hujah ini digunakan oleh Zainal Kling melalui Majlis Profesor Negara utk memberi indikasi bahawa "mat Indera yang menyerang Balai Polis Bkt Kepong" adalah pengkhianat negara kerana beliau menyerang Balai Polis Tanah Melayu, bukan Balai Polis British.
Hujah yang sama digunakan oleh para sejarawan euro-sentrik yang mengatakan para pejuang kemerdekaan Tanah Melayu seperti Tok Janggut, Dato Bahaman, Dol Said, Abd Rahman Limbong, Dato Maharaja Lela, semuanya sebagai pengkhianat negara.
Polemik sejarah ini dilihat sebagai suatu isu yang paradoks bagi para pengkaji sejarah. Ternyata, yang dikatakan "sejarah" itu sebenarnya boleh berubah.


1- Daripada Amirul Mukminin Abi Hafsh Umar Al-Khattab, berkata: “Aku mendengar Rasulullah s.a.w bersabda”: “Bahawasanya sesuatu amalan itu bergantung kepada niat, dan bahawasanya bagi setiap manusia itu mendapat balasan yang ia niatkan. Maka barangsiapa yang berhijrah kepada Allah dan Rasul-Nya, maka hijrahnya itu adalah kepada Allah dan Rasul-Nya. Dan barangsiapa yang berhijrah kerana dunia yang ingin ia meraihnya atau kerana seorang wanita yang ingn dikahwininya, maka hijrahnya itu adalah atass apa yang ia berhijrah kerananya. [Riwayat Bukhari dan Muslim]

2- Niat merupakan suatu elemen penting dalam kehidupan manusia. Niat ialah lintasan hati, niat ialah motivasi, niat ialah gerakan hati, niat ialah tujuan, niat ialah ingatan dalam hati.

3- Menurut hadith, niat adalah permulaan setiap perbuatan. Niat itu kadangkala jelas, dan kadangkala samar.

4- Dalam kehidupan seharian, ada perkara atau perbuatan yang kita sedar dan berniat secara jelas, tetapi ada perbuatan kita yang kita tidak berniat secara jelas (samar) sebelum melakukannya.

5- Hakikatnya, niat bukanlah semata-mata apa yang kita niatkan secara khusus seperti niat solat atau niat puasa, tetapi ia juga berlaku dalam keadaan yang tidak kita sedari kerana ia adalah lintasan hati yang menggerakkan perbuatan kita. Oleh yang demikian, sekiranya kita sedar apa yang kita niatkan, ia akan membawa implikasi yang lebih baik terhadap perbuatan kita.

6- Hadith ini adalah berkaitan dengan peristiwa hijrah Nabi s.a.w dan para sahabat dari Mekah ke Madinah. Dalam rombongan hijrah tersebut, ada seorang lelaki yang keluar pergi berhijrah bukan kerana Allah dan Rasul, tetapi kerana ingin mengahwini seorang wanita yang bernama Ummu Qais.
7- Oleh yang demikian, Nabi Muhammad s.a.w menyebutkan hadith ini sebagai ingatan kepada para sahabat sekaliannya.

8- Hadith ini adalah hadith yang sangat mahsyur. Ia adalah hadith yang mutawatir dan mesej dalamnya sangat penting untuk panduan kaum Muslimin.


[Konsep Niat: Apa itu Niat?]

9- Secara umumnya, niat ialah lintasan hati, ingatan hati, motif, impian, kehendak, tujuan, harapan, halatuju dan motivasi.
10- Menurut Kamus Dewan, niat bermakna: a) Tujuan atau maksud sesuatu perbuatan; b) Ingatan hati; dan c) Janji dalam hati untuk melakukan sesuatu jika terkabul sesuatu yang dihajati.

11- Dalam mukadimah kitab Mustika Hadis, disebutkan bahawa niat ialah a) Tujuan yang membangkitkan dan menggerakkan hati seseorang hendak melakukan sesuatu perkara; b) Perasaan tergerak untuk melakukan sesuatu perkara.

12- Justeru, niat merupakan asas penilaian baik buruk sesuatu.

13- Perlakuan dan perbuatan kita adalah pengiktirafan terhadap apa yang kita niatkan.

14- Niat boleh jadi baik atau buruk. Apa-apa yang diniatkan baik akan dapat nilai kebaikannya, dan apa-apa yang diniatkan buruk akan dapat nilai keburukannya.

15- Menurut Mustafa Abdul Rahman dalam syarah Arba’in Nawawiyah, dalam istilah syarak, niat ialah tergerak hati ke arah satu pekerjaan untuk mencari keredhaan Allah dan menyatakan perasaan tunduk dan patuh kepada Allah.

16- Oleh itu, niat yang diiktiraf di sisi syarak ialah niat yang baik dan terpuji, bukan niat yang buruk.

17- Kesimpulannya, niat ialah suatu input yang menghasilkan output perbuatan. Oleh sebab setiap perbuatan bermula dengan niat, maka perbuatan itu adalah berdasarkan kemahuan dan pilihan seseorang. Maka, dialah yang bertanggungjawab atas perbuatannya sendiri atas sebab niatnya itu.

18- Beberapa ayat Al-Quran yang berkaitan dengan tema hadith ini: Surah Hud, ayat 15; Surah Al-Syura, ayat 20; dan Surah Al-Nisa, ayat 114.


[Implikasi Niat Terhadap Kehidupan]

19- Niat yang baik boleh membawa implikasi yang baik, manakala niat yang tidak baik membawa kepada implikasi yang tidak baik.

20- Dalam ilmu psikologi, niat dikaitkan dengan "motivasi".

21- Perkataan "motivasi" datang daripada perkataan "motif" yang bermaksud tujuan.

22- Niat = Motivasi = Motif + Aksi

23- Oleh itu, niat atau motivasi adalah tujuan yang membuahkan amal/perbuatan.

24- Dalam psikologi Barat, motivasi ialah dorongan atau desakan untuk seseorang bertingkahlaku bagi mendapatkan sesuatu ganjaran.

25- Teori ini dibangunkan dan dikembangkan oleh tokoh psikologis Behaviourism seperti Abraham Maslow. Malah beliau merangka teori “Hierarchy of Needs” bagi mengembangkan teori motivasi beliau.

26- Menurutnya, motivasi manusia hadir untuk memenuhi lima matlamat keperluan utama manusia (Hierarchy of Needs): a) Fisiologi; b) Keselamatan (safety); c) Kepunyaan Kendiri (self-belonging); d) Harga Kendiri (Self-esteem); dan e) Aktualisasi Diri (Self actualization).

27- Menurut teori ini, setiap tingkatan keperluan perlu dipenuhi secara bertingkat. Dalam kata lain, Abraham Maslow mengatakan setiap manusia perlu memenuhi peringkat yang paling bawah dengan sempurna sebelum boleh mencapai peringkat kedua dan kefahaman ini dikritik hebat oleh para psikologis sendiri.

28- Dalam konteks Islam, terdapat satu Hadith Qudsi, di mana Allah menyatakan “Aku adalah menurut sangkaan hamba-Ku”. Untuk mengaitkannya dengan diskusi kita berkaitan niat, kita perlu mengawal niat kita menjadi positif.

29- Kawalan hati dan niat menjadi positif inilah yang kita kenali sebagai 'husnu zhon’ (sangkaan baik).

30- Niat yang baik bermula dengan sangkaan yang baik dan positif.

31- Niat yang baik, murni dan terpuji akan membawa kepada ikhlas.

32- Lebih menarik, kita perlu mendidik diri agar mengahalakan niat menjadi "kehendak"‟ berbanding "kemahuan"

33- Kehendak membawa konotasi keinginan dengan kerelaan hati, manakala kemahuan memberi konotasi keinginan dengan dorongan atau desakan luar.

34- Oleh itu, niat dengan faktor "kehendak" boleh membawa kepada keikhlasan.

35- Niat adalah aspek dalaman manusia. Ia adalah ibadah jiwa.

36- Manakala, tindakan atau perbuatan adalah aspek luaran manusia. Ia adalah ibadah anggota. [Niat vs. Angan-angan]

37- Niat yang tidak disusuli dengan perbuatan dikhuatiri akan jatuh menjadi angan-angan.

38- Niat seperti ini tidak dilandasi dengan ilmu. Justeru, niat seperti ini adalah niat yang buruk dan wajar dijauhi.

39- Sebagai contoh, seseorang itu berniat untuk menjadi pandai, tetapi dia tidak berusaha dengan sedaya upaya belajar untuk menjadi pandai. Maka, dia sebenarnya sedang berangan-angan.


40- Justeru, untuk memahami niat dan implikasi positifnya, kita perlu hubungkan dengan beberapa elemen lain yang penting dan berkaitan.

41- Niat – Ilmu – Amal – Spiritual. Niat mesti dilandasi dengan ilmu, yang akan menggerakkan amal. Aspek spiritual adalah elemen kawalan yang mengawal niat, ilmu dan amal agar selari antara satu dengan yang lain.


[Niat dan Rahmat Allah]

42- Nabi Muhammad s.a.w bersabda yang antara lainnya bermaksud “Allah s.w.t menetapkan sesuatu kebaikan dan kejahatan. Barangsiapa yang tergerak hatinya untuk suatu kebaikan walaupun dia belum melakukannya, maka dicatatkan baginya satu kebaikan penuh baginya. Sekiranya dia melakukannya, maka digandakan baginya pahala untuk amalan tersebut. Dan barangsiapa yang berniat untuk melakukan suatu kejahatan, tetapi ia tidak melakukannya, maka dituliskan satu kebaikan penuh baginya, dan sekiranya dia melakukannya, maka dicatatkan satu kejahatan baginya."

43- Menariknya, hadith ini menunjukkan betapa besarnya Rahmat Allah kepada kita. dengan hanya berniat tanpa melakukan sesuatu yang diniatkan itu, Allah memberikan satu kebaikan penuh kepada kita.

44- Bagi niat kebaikan, apabila dilakukan perbuatan yang diniatkan itu, maka beroleh kita pahala dan kebaikan berganda. Manakala bagi niat yang buruk, jika dilakukan hanya dicatatkan satu keburukan sahaja bagi orang yang melakukannya.


[Niat Hadir dari Hati]

45- Hakikatnya, niat adalah suatu perbuatan yang lahir dari hati.

46- Hati adalah anggota rohani manusia. Hati berkaitan dengan akal, jiwa dan roh.

47- Imam Al-Ghazali menyatakan bahawa hati (qalb), akal (aql), jiwa (al-nafs), juga roh (ruh) adalah dimensi-dimensi diri rohani manusia yang disebut beliau sebagai Al-Latifah Al-Ruhaniah/ Rabbaniyah

48- Niat muncul daripada diri rohani manusia yang akhirnya terpamer pada perbuatannya.

49- Menurut KH Abdullah Gymnastiar (Aa Gym), teko mengeluarkan isinya. Jika isinya kopi, maka kopi yang akan keluar daripada teko apabila isinya dituang keluar. Jika isinya teh, maka teh lah yang akan keluar.

50- Maksudnya, perbuatan kita adalah apa yang keluar daripada niat hati kita. Jika kita melakukan perbuatan baik, maka niat kita adalah niat yang baik. Begitu juga sebaliknya.


[Wacana Tambahan: Niat dalam Ibadah Khusus]

1- Di dalam mazhab Imam Syafi‟i r.h., niat merupakan salah satu rukun kepada semua amalan ibadah khusus. Niat berlaku pada ketika kita ingin memulakan sesuatu amalan.

2- Walaubagaimanapun, dalam ibadah khusus, niat sesuatu ibadah itu ada tempat dan waktunya yang tertentu.

3- Sebagai contoh, niat mandi junub pada ketika jirusan pertama air sampai ke anggota badan; niat solat ialah pada ketika kita bertakbiratul ihram “Allahu Akbar”; niat puasa pada malam hari sebelum fajar keesokan harinya.

4- Begitulah yang digariskan dalam mazhab kita, mazhab Syafi'i yang menjadi kerangka kefahaman dan amalan feqah bagi masyarakat di Alam Melayu ini.


[Tentang Lafaz Niat]

5- Dalam mazhab Imam Syafi'i juga, kita diajarkan tentang lafaz niat. Lafaz niat ialah melafazkan niat amalan tersebut sebelum berniat di dalam hati secara khusus ketika melakukan amalan ibadah tersebut.

6- Pada sesetengah Imam mazhab yang lain tidak meletakkan lafaz niat sebagai suatu yang sunat, tetapi pada pandangan sebahagian ulama-ulama Syafi'iyah, lafaz niat adalah suatu perkara yang penting untuk membantu memantapkan fokus dan kusyuk serta menambah-kuat kesedaran dan kejelasan kita ketika berniat di dalam hati.


[Tentang Niat dalam Solat]
7- Niat dalam solat ialah pada ketika kita bertakbiratulIhram. Lazimnya, kita akan membaca lafaz solat sebelum mengangkat takbiratulIhram dan ketika takbir itulah masanya kita berniat di dalam hati.

8- Masalah timbul apabila lafaz niat itu terlalu panjang, dan kita terpaksa menyusun niat dalam hati seperti lafaz niat tadi.

9- Sebagai contoh, lafaz solat fardhu Maghrib: “usholli farhal maghribi thalatha raka’atin adaan lillahi ta’ala” – “sahaja aku sembahyang fardhu Maghrib tiga rakaat tunai kerana Allah ta‟ala”.

10- Ini mengakibatkan masa yang kita ambil untuk bertakbir menjadi panjang dan lama.

11- Masalah ini dapat diatasi sekiranya kita menambah ilmu kita tentang memahami niat solat ini.

12- Para ulama sebenarnya telah mengajarkan kita bahawa dalam niat solat itu terdapat tiga unsur asa yang wajib ada dalam niat: 1) Qasad; 2) Ta’rud; dan 3) Ta’yin.

13- Qasad ialah mensahajakan/ menetapkan amal perbuatan kita (“sahaja aku sembahyang”); Ta’rud ialah menyatakan status solat sebagai fardhu (“solat fardhu”); dan Ta’yin ialah menyatakan solat yang kita kerjakan itu (“Maghrib”).

14- Sebenarnya cukuplah kita berniat atau terlintas di dalam hati kita dengan “sahaja aku solat fardhu Maghrib”.

15- Walau bagaimanapun, sekiranya kita memahami niat sebagai lintasan hati, panjang mana pun bait-bait niat kita itu pasti tidak menjadi masalah kepada kita.


WalLahu a'lam.
Hidup Biar Berjasa!


MOHAMMAD FAZRIL B. MOHD SALEH
Presiden
Persatuan Kebangsaan Pelajar Islam Malaysia (PKPIM)


26 Oktober 2014/ 02 Muharram 1436H
Kampung Pinang, Kamunting
fazrilsaleh@gmail.com.

Seminar Sains Ketamadunan 2015

Tema:
"Sains Ketamadunan Pasca Ibnu Khaldun"

Tarikh:
7hb & 8 hb Mac 2015 (2 hari)
 
Masa:
08:30 pagi - 05:00 petang
 
Tempat:
Bilik Syura, Kolej Dar al-Hikmah, Sg. Ramal Dalam, Kajang
 
Yuran Pendaftaran:
RM 60.00 sahaja

Pertanyaan lanjut, hubungi 013-2775313 (Fazril)


[Senarai Pembentang dan Topik Pembentangan untuk Seminar Sains Ketamadunan 2015]

1. Dr. Ghazali Basri,
"Transformasi Konsep Tamadun Pendekatan Profetik - Pengalaman Kristian dan Islam: Sebuah Penilaian"


2. Dato' Dr. Siddiq Fadzil,
"Ketamadunan dalam Refleksi Persuratan Melayu"


3. Prof Emeritus Dr. Shaharir Mohd Zain,
"Kosmologi Bangsa Melayu dan Pembangunan Ketamadunannya"


4. Dr. Mohamad Alinor Abdul Kadir,
"Sains Ketamadunan Menurut Pemikir-Pemikir Inggeris Moden"


5. Mohd Nasir Mohd Tap,
"Tipologi Pemikiran Muslim dalam Dialog Ketamadunan Islam-Barat"


6. Mohd Fazril Mohd Saleh,
"Tinjauan Terhadap Kajian Tamadun Islam Perspektif Marshall Hodgson"


7. Dr. Zulkifli Hassan,
"Renaissance Islam Abad ke-21: Realiti atau Mitos"


8. Dr. Rumaizuddin Ghazali,
"Ketamadunan Menurut Said Ramadhan al-Buti"


9. Dr. Nurdeng Deuraseh,
"Pemikiran Peradaban Malek Bennabi"


10. Dr. Noriah Mohamed,
"Pemikiran Jawa dalam Beberapa Karya Warisan Jawa"


11. Hazman Baharom,
"Pengenalan Analisis Sistem-Dunia Immanuel Wallerstein"


12. Faridah Mohd Tap,
"Analisis Ringkas Manifesto Komunis Marx dengan Irtafaqat Shah Waliullah al-Dihlawi"


13. Dr Shahrizal Mohd Zin,
"Westphalia dalam Pembentukan Tamadun Eropah dan Kesannya pada Undang-Undang Antarabangsa"


14. Dr. Clarissa Lee
"Teori Spekulatif: Ilmu Mantik dalam Interpretasi Teori Kuantum di Anjang Timur-Barat”








PERANGAI BERGANTUNG KEPADA DIRI SENDIRI:
TINJAUAN RINGKAS TERHADAP DUA BAB AWAL

Mohammad Fazril Bin Mohd Saleh
Persatuan Kebangsaan Pelajar Islam Malaysia (PKPIM)

PRAWACANA
Kemunduran dan keterbelakangan umat Islam dan bangsa Melayu bukanlah suatu yang baharu diperkatakan. Sejak era sebelum merdeka lagi, para reformis kerapkali melakukan kritik keras terhadap bangsanya sendiri dengan harapan untuk membangun bangsanya kembali gagah dan bergerak maju ke hadapan.

Allahyarham Zainal Abidin Bin Ahmad atau lebih dikenali sebagai Pendita Za’ba merupakan seorang tokoh cendekia Melayu yang cukup istimewa. Kepedulian beliau terhadap umat dan bangsa ini terpamer dalam kegiatan dan perjuangan selama beliau menjalani kehidupan di alam fana ini. Dalam kertas kerja yang sederhana ini akan dipaparkan beberapa buah fikiran Za’ba tentang nasib umat ini dan bagaimana mahu membangun semula bangsa Melayu-Islam ini menjadi bangsa yang mulia dan terhormat.

NUKILAN YANG KONTROVERSI
Za’ba merupakan seorang tokoh penulis yang prolifik. Tulisan-tulisan beliau dimuatkan dalam banyak majalah dan periodikal yang wujud pada zaman sekitar awal 1920-an sehingga lewat 1950-an. Buku yang bertajuk “Perangai Bergantung kepada Diri Sendiri” merupakan himpunan tulisan beliau yang tidak pernah diterbitkan pada ketika beliau masih hidup. Ia hanya diterbitkan dalam tahun 1982 setelah himpunan tulisan beliau ini dijumpai oleh warisnya, Puan Zaharah Za’ba dan diserahkan kepada Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka untuk dicetak. 


Tulisan ini sebenarnya adalah merupakan sambungan daripada sebuah himpunan tulisan beliau yang dikenali sebagai Risalah Pertama yang diterbitkan dengan judul Umbi Kemajuan dan Falsafah Taqdir. Justeru, boleh dikatakan bahawa Perangai Bergantung kepada Diri Sendiri merupakan Risalah Kedua dan Risalah Ketiga yang ditulis oleh Za’ba sebagai buah fikiran beliau terhadap permasalahan umat.

Malang sekali, Risalah Kedua ini tidak diterbitkan kerana kontroversi Risalah Pertama yang beliau terbitkan sebelum itu. Risalah Pertama telahpun diharamkan oleh DYMM Sultan Perak pada ketika itu atas sebab tentangan hebat oleh para ulama di Negeri Perak terhadap isi kandungan bukunya itu. Justeru, bagi mengelak polemik dan pertentangan dengan para ulama tradisional, beliau mengambil keputusan untuk tidak menerbitkan Risalah Kedua ini sehinggalah akhir hayat beliau.

Mengapa tulisan beliau ini cukup kontroversi? Ini disebabkan oleh pemikiran beliau yang melawan norma pemikiran Islam tradisonal yang dominan ketika itu. Tanpa menafikan peranan para ulama tradisional dan ketinggian ilmu mereka, penulis merasakan Za’ba sebenarnya cuba menganjak cara berfikir umat ketika itu yang salah dalam memahami konsep taqdir sehingga membuatkan mereka jatuh ke dalam sikap sambil lewa dalam bekerja dan bermalas-malasan dan urusan harian.

Seperkara lagi yang mungkin menjadi isu besar yang dipertelingkahkan ialah berkenaan isu ijtihad. Za’ba, seperti juga para pemikir reformis ‘kaum Muda’ yang lain, mengajak umat Islam dan bangsa ini jangan hanya bertaqlid buta sahaja. Mereka menyeru kepada penggunaan akal fikiran dan keluar daripada kepompong sikap suka meminta-minta.

TEMA-TEMA BESAR DARIPADA BAB 1 DAN BAB 2
Buku “Perangai Bergantung kepada Diri Sendiri” ini terdiri daripada dua bahagian: 1) Risalah Kedua; dan 2) Risalah Ketiga. Risalah Kedua mengandungi empat bab, manakala Risalah Ketiga mengandungi empat bab lagi. Beberapa tema-tema besar, khusus dalam Bab 1 (Wajibnya Bagi Mendapat Kejayaan) dan Bab 2 (Kekurangan Kita dalam Sifat Ini) tulisan beliau ini dipaparkan seperti di bawah:

1. Konsep “Al-I’timadu A’la Al-Nafs” Sebagai Sifat Terpuji
Menurut Za’ba, bergantung kepada diri sendiri adalah sifat terpuji sebagaimana yang dicontohan oleh Nabi Muhammad s.a.w sebagai ‘makarim al-akhlaq’. Bergantung kepada diri sendiri bermaksud percaya dan yakin dengan usaha dan kebolehan diri sendiri dan tidak menjadi lemah dan suka meminta-minta atau selalu mengaharap kepada bantuan orang lain.

2. Kewajiban Mencapai Kejayaan
Pada hakikatnya, manusia mampu untuk berusaha mencapai kejayaan kerana Tuhan memberikan manusia aqal kepada manusia dan keupayaan untuk berikhtiyar. Maka tiada alasan untuk manusia tidak beusaha mencapai kejayaan.

3. Kewajiban Berusaha Dengan Keupayaan Sendiri
Setiap amalan manusia akan dihitung oleh Allah dan diberikan ganjaran kebaikan atau balasan keburukan atas apa yang ia lakukan. Justeru, setiap individu adalah wajib untuk berusaha sendiri dan yakin dengan kebolehannya.

4. Kejayaan Bangsa Bergantung Kepada Individu-Individunya
Umat yang kuat dan maju lahir daripada individu-individu yang kuat dan maju. Sesuatu umat atau bangsa itu dibentuk oleh individu-individunya. Maka, kekuatan dan kemajuan sesuatu bangsa adalah berdasarkan kemajuan individu yang membentuknya. Justeru untuk membangun umat dan bangsa yang maju, individu-individunya harus maju terlebih dahulu.

5. Kejayaan Di Dunia Bergantung Kepada Usaha Diri Sendiri
Kejayaan di dunia adalah berdasarkan sejauh mana usaha yang dilakukan. Kejayaan tidak akan hadir daripada sifat suka meminta-minta dan mengharap pertolongan orang lain melainkan dengan keyakinan terhadap usaha diri sendiri.

6. Keselamatan Di Akhirat Bergantung Kepada Usaha Diri Sendiri
Untuk memperoleh balasan baik di Akhirat bukanlah semata-mata dengan mengharap syafaat Nabi Muhammad s.a.w, atau dengan pertolongan dan doa orang lain, tetapi mestilah dengan usaha dan kesungguhan individu untuk beramal soleh dan melakukan kebajikan.


KHATIMAH
Kepedulian Za’ba terhadap nasib umat dan bangsa Melayu adalah ciri seorang intelektual yang merakyat dan tahu akan peranannya dalam membangunkan masyarakatnya. Nukilan beliau walaupun kontroversi tetapi masih dalam laras bahasa yang sopan dan terhormat. Bab 1 dan Bab 2 dalam buku ini masih perlu kepada kupasan lanjut. Mesej daripada dua bab awal ini adalah jelas. Manusia adalah makhluk yang dipertanggungjawabkan untuk menjalani kehidupannya dengan daya upaya dan usahanya sendiri kerana ia diberikan akal dan iktiyar. Bangsa yang ingin maju hanya dapat bangun dengan memajukan individu-individu yang membentuk bangsa tersebut. Justeru, setiap individu perlu yakin dan percaya kepada kebolehan dan potensi diri. Manusia bukan hanya perlu bergantung kepada diri sendiri dalam urusan duniawi, tetapi juga dalam urusan ukhrawi kerana ganjaran dan balasan baik ataupun buruk adalah atas apa yang dilakukannya sendiri.


Wallahu a’lam bi al-sowab


Mohammad Fazril Bin Mohd Saleh
25 September 2013, 06.21 petang
Sungai Chincin, Gombak Selangor

013-2775313 / fazrilsaleh@gmail.com / fb: Peminggir Kota



 
Montgomery Watt and The Last Prophet (s.a.w)

Mohammad Fazril Bin Mohd Saleh
International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM)




Introduction

The Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) has become the target for Islam’s adversaries and their armies of missionaries including orientalists who have aroused suspicions and propagated allegations against the Last Prophet (s.a.w) and his message. According to Edward W. Said, an orientalist is anyone who teaches, conducting research or writes about the Orient either in its specific or its general aspect. Since the end of European medieval era, occidental intellectuals has been working hardly, systematically, and creatively to produce a lot of works about Islam with prejudice and unfair conclusion. This phenomenon is a result of confrontation between The West and Islam where the basis of this clash is religion. Their objective has always been to distort the image of the Last Prophet and to deny him as a legitimate prophet. Nevertheless, the evidence of prophethood of the Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) is crystal clear. It can be derived from the Holy Quran, the hadith and sirah literature, the miracles (mu’jizat), the prophesied glad tidings in the previous revealed scriptures, the Last Prophet’s (s.a.w) conduct and morals, and the recognition and acknowledgement by the academia. Abdul Hameed Siddeeqi, in his book Prophethood in Islam, argues that in the history of religions, the Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) is known as the only prophet whose biography is written in a detailed and documented way that made him qualified to be the role model for mankind. Interestingly, all his words and deeds were recorded and preserved with precision and verification based on reliable transmission records which then transmitted from one generation to another.[1]
 
This paper is basically dealing with the views of an outstanding orientalist by the name of William Montgomery Watt towards the Last Prophet of Islam, Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w). Consists of five subtopics, the paper starts with Watt’s biographical background, consists of his life, education, experiences and works (William Montgomery Watt: Biographical Background). Then, we go further to discover in brief his scholarly works especially those writings about the Last Prophet (s.a.w) in Watt’s Works on the Last Prophet (s.a.w). Perhaps, some authors and scholars regarded Watt’s works as the most influential ‘interpretation of Islam’ in Europe. Then, as we think that it is important to lay a foundation in understanding basic important concepts before we go to highlight Watt’s views on the Last Prophet (s.a.w), we have come out with these two subtopics: The Worldview of Islam: On Sirah al-Nabawiyah, and Prophethood: Revealing the Truth about the Last Prophet (s.a.w). In The Worldview of Islam: On Sirah al-Nabawiyah, a brief discussion on the understanding of the life history of the Last Prophet (sirah al-nabawiyah) will be taken place in the light of the worldview of Islam. An elaborative argument on the concept and significance of the Last Prophet and his prophethood will then being discussed in Prophethood: Revealing the Truth about the Last Prophet (s.a.w). Consequently, before we arrive at the conclusion, The Last Prophet (s.a.w): Watt’s Perception will become our final topic to be dealt with. Here, we try to analyze some false claims and misleading arguments done by Watt against the Last Prophet (s.a.w). Then, these fallacies will be answered and enlightened, in the light of the authentic Muslim scholars’ view.

William Montgomery Watt: Biographical Background
 
William Montgomery Watt was a famous scholar who had written many books about Islam and the Last Prophet. He was born in Scotland on 14th March 1909 and died on 24th October 2006 at the age 97. He was married to Jean Donaldson, together both of them were granted one son and four daughters. Educated at George Watson's College, he then studied at the universities of Edinburgh, Jena and Oxford. Basically he was specialized in theology and philosophy, however, later on when he learned about through a long conversation with an Indian man. Then he decided to learn Arabic and because of his keen to learn about Islam, in 1939 he was ordained in a church and as the chaplain of the Bishop of Jerusalem.[2]
 
He was an Emeritus Professor in Arabic and Islamic Studies at the University of Edinburgh. He was known as non-Muslim interpreters of Islam in the west.  In addition to that he was also served as Emeritus Professor of Arabic and Islamic Studies at the University of Edinburgh.[3] Through Edinburgh University Press he has publish circa 30 books basically about Islam, The Last Prophet and Christianity. Some of his works even translated into other languages and also amongst the bestseller up to today.[4] Montgomery Watt’s passion to study Islam had always served him the ability of seeing other people’s point of view towards Islam. He also witness how the western historians’ prejudice and bias towards Islam. He even mentioned that the historians only make such statement about Islam due to the fact that they were only supporting the crusades. Hence, through the bias and prejudice is how the Europeans see the Muslim and that was basically the opposite of his faith towards Christianity which practices positivity. To implement the positivity as a Christian, he often refers to the verses in the Qur’an as his basic method to the daily practices.[5]


Watt’s Works on the Last Prophet (s.a.w) 

Montgomery Watt had written many books which deals with Islam and the Last Prophet. The most famous three books written by him: Muhammad at Mecca (1953), Muhammad at Medina (1956), and Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman (1961), which focus on one person that is The Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w), acknowledged by experts to be classics in the field.[6] Of all his works, Muhammad at Mecca (1953) and Muhammad at Medina (1956) are among the earliest works he had published. These two books have since been republished several times and also been translated in a number of European languages, as well as Arabic.[7] After these two books he then wrote another book, Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman (1961). This work is the summary of the two books mentioned before. Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman talks about the Last Prophet’s (s.a.w) history from the very beginning to the end. It is also serves as an excellent introduction to one of the world's major religions.[8] This book contains more of Montgomery Watt’s opinion, and in fact it is a short account of the life and achievements of one of the great figures of history. In addition to that, Montgomery Watt wrote this book in chronological manner; from the Last Prophet’s childhood up to the last moment of the Last Prophet (s.a.w). Montgomery Watt elaborated each point he proposed in detail, for instance, in the second part of this book; the call to prophethood, he break it into several sections such as the rise of Muhammad as the Last Prophet (s.a.w), the messages he brought, the first Muslims and the influence of Judaism and Christianity. It was actually accordingly to one another how Montgomery Watt explain it.


The Worldview of Islam: On Sirah al-Nabawiyah

In Islamic intellectual tradition, Muslim scholars, in dealing with the life history of the Last Prophet (Sirah al-Nabawiyyah), used three main sources: the Holy Qur’an, the Hadith (traditions/reports) and historical as well as biographical literatures known as sirah or maghazi.[9]These three sources are complementary and supplementary on another. Anyone who wants to obtain fair view of the Prophet’s life and activities has to depend on these three sources. This is the proper methodology on studying sirah al-Nabawiyah or the life history of the Last Prophet (s.a.w). 

In his works, William Montgomery Watt deals a lot with the life history of Last Prophet (s.a.w). As a scholar and orientalist, indeed he was using a systematic way of studying the life and activities of Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w). In other words, he has proper system and methodology of study and dealt with those three main sources as being used in Islamic intellectual tradition (the Qur’an, the Hadith and Sirah literature). However, his treatment to these main sources can be considered as misleading and sometimes out of context, or might be shadowed by certain hidden agenda. How did he deal with these sources? Mohar Ali is managed to analyze and synthesis several works done by some leading orientalists including Watt and concludes that orientalist: (a) considering the Quranic evidences or hadith and sirah reports in isolation without supplementing it with information or accounts contain in other sources, (b) taking a passage or account in the Quran, the hadith or sirah literature out of context and put wrong interpretation on it, and (c) take only a part of passages or reports in those three sources to support an assumption or a particular part of view.[10] Not only that, Watt was also suffering from confusion in understanding the worldview of Islam that is the ‘aqidah of Islam itself.[11] In other words, Watt’s attitude and false claims towards the life history of the Last Prophet (s.a.w) were the results of his confusion and misunderstanding of the very nature of Islam as projected by its worldview. For instance, in his book What is Islam (1990), Watt claims: “…while much of what valuable in the nomadic Arabic outlook has been taken into the central core of Islam and there transformed, there would also appear to be matters which have been given an Islamic dress without any fundamental change…”[12]. It is absolutely a false statement that describes Islam as a derivation of cultural and philosophical elements. The fact is that this wahy is final, and it not only confirms the truth of preceding revelations in their original forms, but includes their substance, separating the truth from cultural creation and ethnic inventions.[13]
 
Muslims believes that ‘aqidah of Islam or worldview of Islam projects the vision of the Reality and Truth. It is a fixed, unchanging, final and absolute vision because it is grounded in and derived from wahy.[14] This is not merely a theoretical claim, for Muslim historical experience has shown that the fundamental element of the worldview such as the conception of God, of the nature of man and of the psychology of the human soul, and the meaning of knowledge, of happiness, of virtue and vices, and of prophethood have no change throughout the long ages of Islamic epoch.[15]
 

Prophethood: Revealing the Truth about the Last Prophet (s.a.w)

Before we go further to analyze Watt’s claims on the Last Prophet (s.a.w) and his life, it is better to have a look at the concept of prophethood. Prophethood (nubuwwah) is a very vital aspect of Islamic creed. Unlike other world religions which faced confusions in their beliefs and religious practices as a result of their confusions in understanding the sources of their religions, Islam promotes a very clear principle of religion, firmed belief and guided rituals. Literally, the Arabic term for prophet, nabi has two possible meanings: (a) the one who conveys the knowledge and information shown to him by Allah, and (b) the one who is of noble and eminent rank and status.[16] These two meanings implies prophet as the one who is special, chosen by God to be revealed the special knowledge from Him, and who is above ordinary people and has a high status that was bestowed on him by God. According to Ibn Taimiyyah, the words nabi (prophet) and nubuwwah (prophethood) are derived from the Arabic verb nabba’a, means to tell. For instance, Surah Al-An’am (6), verse 143 reads, “…informs (nabbiu’ni) me with your knowledge if you are truthful.”[17]
 
Meanwhile technically, as we regard prophethood as an Islamic term, some views and definitions given by great Muslim scholars will be highlighted here. Abu Hassan Al-Ash’ari defines prophet as an informer about the unseen.[18] Quite similar to Al-Ash’ari, Ibn Hazm argues that a prophet is whoever has been informed by Allah about an unseen matter or a matter before it exists.[19] For Ibn Taimiyah, he considers prophet as the one who has been informed by Allah about His commands, prohibitions, and other knowledge, and they informs the people about all the commands, prohibitions, and knowledge they received from Allah. These three definitions imply two major aspects of prophethood, communication between God and mankind, and knowledge acquired from this communication. 

            The rejection against prophethood in Islam indicates the rejection against the whole religion. Without vivid concept and proper understanding of prophethood, might be Muslims will be suffered from confusions in conducting their religious and secular life, just like the other religions. In fact, as far as the nature of Islam is concerned, Muslims believed that the religion of Islam as not merely a code for private religious rituals and practices. Rather it is the way of life (al-deen) whose source is wahy (divine revelation), confirmed by religion, and affirmed by intellectual and intuitive principles.[20] Israr Ahmad Khan argues that wahy means communication which derived from the Arabic verb “ahwa” that is for instances, denotes sentence of “he communicated”.[21] God sends His words to His creation through an imperceptible message of communication called as wahy.[22]
 
            In the theory of communication, scholars agreed upon these four basic elements: source (sender), the message, channel and receiver. Thus, in the process of revelation, God can be referring as the source or sender, and human, represented by the Prophets denotes the receiver. Meanwhile wahy indicates both message and channel. This message, known as wahy, was revealed by God to His chosen Prophets as mentions in the Holy Qur’an, “O ye the Messenger of Allah do communicate what is being sent to down you, if you do not, you would not have fulfilled your mission”.[23] This verse clearly indicates the task of the Prophets who received wahy from God and obliged to fulfill the mission of spreading the truth of Tawhidic teachings, and as we mentioned before the ultimate source for Islam is wahy. Therefore, the message of Islam can only be known through the Prophets who has been revealed the wahy. 

As far as wahy is concerned, the authenticity of it should be clarified and the relationship between wahy and prophethood has to be further elaborated. Here, in short, we provide a beautiful explanation on wahy with its relation to prophethood by Syed Muhammad Naquib al-Attas. Al-Attas refers wahy as the speech of God in which revealing about Himself, His creation, the relation between them, and the way to salvation communicated to His chosen Prophet and Messenger. [24] He argues that wahy was not revealed by sound or letter, but it represented in words that been conveyed by the Prophet to the mankind in the new comprehensible linguistic form (Arabic Language of Qur`an) and without confusion with the Prophet’s own subjectivity and cognitive imagination. [25]
 
From this explanation, we can conclude that Islamic perspective towards divine revelation is that God has not only created human beings, but also continually guided them by raising series of prophethood starting with Adam and ending it with the last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) and it stated that every prophet or messenger must have received revelation (wahy) from God, which His divine guidance (hidayah), directing people to lead their lives in accordance with the absolute command of God. The command is of two kinds, that it is the instructions and the prohibitions. Those who believed and obeyed the command are believers, and those who rejected are condemned as unbelievers. That means prophethood is an extremely important need for human being and this need is undeniable. Israr Ahmad Khan highlights some significance of the prophets towards human development. Among others are: (1) prophets laid the foundation of the first comprehensive human society, (2) prophets helped mankind to return to their very nature (reorientation of man), (3) prophets implemented human civilization, and (4) prophets developed human intellectual capacity.[26] All these roles of the prophets can only being successfully accomplished by the reception of divine guidance, known as wahy and it were the prophets alone who endowed with this privilege of receiving divine revelation.

Furthermore, in Al-‘Aqidah Al-Tahawiyyah written by Abu Jaafar Al-Tahawi, mentions that prophethood as a mercy from Allah to His slaves. He further argues that sending messengers is one of Allah’s greatest graces upon mankind, particularly in sending Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w). Allah says, “Indeed Allah conferred a great favor on the believers when He sent among them a messenger (Muhammad) from among themselves, reciting unto them His verses, and purifying them, and instructing them the Book and the Wisdom, while before they had been in manifest error.”[27] We have discussed briefly the concept of prophethood as being understood in Islam. Yet, to believe in Prophet Muhammad as the legitimate and the Last Prophet is also a part of the elements of prophethood in Islamic belief.


The Last Prophet (s.a.w): Watt’s Perception
 
There are too many false claims as well as allegations made by the orientalists in general, and by Watt in specific. In several works of Watt, he has arrived at some conclusions about the Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w). Among major points raised by him will be discussed here: (1) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) as the author of the Qur’an, (2) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) was influenced by the idea and facts from pagan’s Arab poetry and other religions, (3) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) lied about the operation of receiving wahy and (4) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) has been confused by Satan in his teachings.

(1) The Last Prophet (s.a.w) as the author of the Qur’an
 
            Watt claims that the Last Prophet (s.a.w) was the one who projected the idea of socio-religious reforms arising out of his time that he claimed as wahy.[28] He admits some similarities between wahy which he regards as the work of the Prophet and works of man’s creative imagination such as drama and poetry in the sense that both types of works have a wide appeal and producing material from the collective unconscious.[29] Thameem Ushama, who critically analyzed this issue has confirmed that Watt had arrived at a misleading conclusion by saying that the Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) may had been mistaken in believing The Qur’an to be a divine message.[30] This conclusion implies that the Holy Qur’an is ‘the product of creative imagination’.[31] Nevertheless, the fact is, wahy is “neither the sudden visions of great poets and artists claim for themselves, nor the apostolic inspiration of the writers of sacred scripture, nor the illuminative intuition of the sages and people of discernment”.[32] Besides, Israr Ahmad Khan put a question for this allegation: “if it was Muhammad himself who developed the book, why he did not, the attribute it to his name?”[33] If the Last Prophet (s.a.w) was the author of the Qur’an, prophet would have undoubtedly hailed by his compatriots as well as the world today as the most remarkable literary genius for producing the work with extraordinary language and messages.[34]

(2) The Last Prophet (s.a.w) was influenced by the idea from pagan’s Arab poetry and other religions 

            From the premise ‘Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) was the author of the Qur’an’ Watt moves to another allegation. For an author, inspiration is crucially needed in order to come out with an outstanding work. Thus, in order to fully utilized his ‘creative imagination’ for an outstanding work of the Qur’an, Watt argues that the Last Prophet (s.a.w) has modified and derived the wahy from the ancient Arab (pagan) poetry and other religions which prevailing in Arabia at the time such as Christianity, Jews and Zoroastrians.[35] Watt seems to has accepted the view of the continuance of pre-Islamic (Jahiliah) attitudes happened in the Qur’an as he try to find similarity of messages in both the Qur’an and the pagan poetry.[36] Not even that, he also arrived at the conclusion the Qur’an in the earliest passage have no insistence on the truth that there is no deity but God.[37] He claims that in the early time of Islam, the doctrine of monotheism is vague and admiration for superior culture like the people of Syria and Iraq (who believe in one God) and influence of Judaism and Christianity made the acceptance of monotheism become easier.[38] Therefore, we are going to answer all these misleading claims by these three arguments: Firstly, as mentioned by M. Mohar Ali, for Muhammad’s (s.a.w) emergence as Prophet must has been marked by something new and better on his part than what was already known. None would pay any attention to him and become his followers if his ideas were not clearly in advance of those of the enlightened Meccans.[39] Secondly, the message of Tawhid and its principles in the Qur’an is very clear, as mentioned for instance in Surah al-Ikhlas (Qur`an: 112) and surah al-Kafirun (Qur`an: 109). Thirdly, it is clear that Islam by its nature was conscious of his own identity from the time of its revelation.[40] When it appeared on the stage of the world history, Islam is already ‘mature’, needing no process of growing up to maturity. Syed Muhammad Naquib al-Attas stressed that wahy religion or revealed religion can only be that which known itself from the very beginning and that self-knowledge comes from wahy itself, not from history.”[41] Other than that, Israr Ahmad Khan argues that the Qur’anic account of many stories is essentially different from the Biblical account, in many respects.[42] The Holy Qur’an is totally different from neither the Pagan’s Arab poetry nor the traditions of other world religions. Moreover, the Qur’an clearly clarifies the differences between Islam and Judeo-Christian traditions and religions.[43]

(3) The Last Prophet (s.a.w) lied about the operation of receiving wahy 

             Muslims believe the Archangel Gabriel (Jibril a.s) was the one whose task was to send wahy from Allah to the Last Prophet (s.a.w). For Watt, the wahy does not mean verbal communication of a text, but rather ‘suggestion’ or ‘inspiration’ to give out the Qur’an and Jibril (a.s) was introduced at a later stage as a conveyer of way. In translating surah al-Najm Watt adopts Bell’s rendering of the expressions wahy and awha as ‘suggestion’ and ‘suggested’. However, these meaning are not all correct for Qur`anic wahy.[44] The meaning of the word changed with the change of the context. Indeed, a common English equivalent for wahy should be communication rather than suggestion.[45] This meaning would fit in all situations.[46] Wahy is maybe of different types depending on the nature of the matter communication. As far as Jibril (a.s) is concerned, Watt mentions “There is no mention of Gabriel (Jibril a.s) in the Qur’an until the Medinan period”.[47] According to M. Mohar Ali, Watt invoked the opinion of Karl Ahrens who said that there is no mention of Jibril in the Meccan passages of the Qur’an. Actually, Watt has misinterpreted the Qur’anic terms, words and passages. Jibril is mentioned several times in the Qur`an (especially in Meccan passages) by several names which refers to the Archangel Jibril (a.s) such as “Rasul Karim”[48] and “al-Ruh”.[49] Both names are refers to the same individual whom mentioned as the conveyer of wahy who is also described as al-amin[50], “nazzala bihi al-ruh al-amin” which means faithful and having been employed as a messenger by God. Moreover, the specific mention of him by the name Jibril as a conveyer of wahy can be found for example in surah al-Baqarah (2): 97.

(4) The Last Prophet (s.a.w) has been confused by Satan in his teachings.

            Perhaps, Watt’s most controversial view on the Last Prophet (s.a.w) is his theory of ‘Satanic verses’.[51] He argues that the Last Prophet (s.a.w) has been outsmarted by Satan who managed to put into his mouth some polytheistic ideas.[52] More ridiculously, he claims that the Satan put these kind of polytheistic ideas during the revelation of surah al-Najm. He claims that ayat 19-23 of surah al-Najm is those verses. Watt says: “it is assumed in Islam that all such Satanic alterations in the Qur’an have been discovered and corrected…”[53] and “…Satan had managed to slip in the false versus of the first version without Muhammad noticing it...”[54] Nevertheless the Holy Qur’an already states that it is impossible.[55] According to Israr Ahmad Khan, the incident involving those verses is totally different with the story raised up by Watt. He corrects Watt as in 5 A.H, when a number of early Islamic community took refuge in Abbysina, the Last Prophet (s.a.w) after having received the complete revelation of surah al-Najm (Qur`an: 53) from Allah, recited it to a large audience comprising the companions and non-believers. In the end as the last words demand for doing prostration (ayat al-sajadah), The Last Prophet (s.a.w) made it (sujud sajadah) and he was followed by the others including the non-believers. Later, the Quraysh, on felt ashamed of their joining in doing prostration to Allah with Prophet s.a.w, and to wash off this stigma started to fabricate the story that they follow the later in prostration because they heard the Last Prophet (s.a.w) praising their idols.[56] Israr Ahmad Khan also in his commentary to this issue argues that almost all the Orientalists described the Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) as a genius. Therefore, how come the he (s.a.w) as an intelligent person cannot realize the nature of the two opposite messages which one is allegedly Satanic verses and the other is genuinely divine versus: the former appreciates the Arab’s chief goddesses and the latter condemn them as falsehood? These two views are too distinct to escape even from an ordinary person’s mind.[57]

Conclusion
 
From our brief survey, we can conclude that William Montgomery Watt was an outstanding orientalist who prolifically wrote about the life and activities of the Last Prophet (s.a.w). However, to certain extent, he has made false claims about the Last Prophet (s.a.w) and fell into misleading. We have analyzed his four main views on Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w): (1) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) as the author of the Qur’an, (2) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) was influenced by the idea and facts from pagan’s Arab poetry and other religions, (3) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) lied about the operation of receiving wahy and (4) the Last Prophet (s.a.w) has been confused by Satan in his teachings. Then we have response them by advancing evidence and proof, even some basic Islamic concepts such as sirah al-Nabawiyyah and al-Nubuwwah which has been discussed before supported our response against Watt’s false views on the Prophet (s.a.w).
 
Therefore, now it is clear to us that any attempt to distort the Last Prophet (s.a.w) image is useless. For Muslims, without him as the messengers of God, we have no means of accessing God. As the chosen one who was given the holy mission by God, the Last Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) as well as the other prophets is infallible. He was the most trustworthy person, the most ideal leader and his life was the most perfect life to be followed by human beings. To accept the Last Prophet (s.a.w) and prophethood means to accept Islam and to deny it indicates the denial of the whole religion. Prophethood indeed is inevitable. Hence, the clear concept of prophethood in Islam is crucially important as it is tightly connected with the revelation or wahy that represents the ultimate sources of Islam.



Cited Bibliography


al-Attas, Syed Muhammad Naquib.   Prolegomena to the Metaphysics of Islam: An Exposition of The Fundamental Elements of The Worldview of Islam, Kuala Lumpur: ISTAC, 1995.

Adi Setia, Mohd Dom.           Worldview of Islam Academy: The Concept, Kuala Lumpur: HAKIM, unpublished manuscript.

Ali, Abdullah Yusuf.  The Holy Qur’an: Translation and Commentary, U.S.A: Amana Corporation, Maryland, 1983.

Ali, Muhammad Mohar.         Sirat al-Nabi and the Orientalist, Madinah: King Fahd Complex of Printing the Holy Quran, 1997.

Holloway, R.   “William Montgomery Watt: A Christian Scholar in Search of Islamic Understanding”. http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/2006/nov/14/guardianobituaries.highereducation (accessed February 20, 2013).

Hillenbrand, Carole     “Professor W. Montgomery Watt: Son of the Presbyterian Manse and Episcopal Priest Who Became a Leading Interpreter of Islam”. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/obituaries/professor-w-montgomery-watt-423394.html (accessed February 20, 2013).

Jah, Omar.  “Al Balagh” in Knowledge, Language, Thought & the Civilization of Islam ed. Wan Mohd Nor Wan Daud, 83-91, Johor Bharu: UTM Press, 2010.

Khan, Israr Ahmad.    Qur`anic Studies: An Introduction, Kuala Lumpur: Zaman Islam Media, 2000.

Khan, Israr Ahmad.    Towards Understanding the Mission of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w., unpublished manuscript

Muhsin, Abdur Radi M. Abdul.         Muhammad's Prophethood Reality or Myth, Riyadh: International Islamic Publishing, 2008.

Richard Holloway, “William Montgomery Watt” The Guardian. Edition 14th  Nov. 2006.

Said, Edward W. Orientalism, New York: Vintage Books, 1929.

Ushama, Thameem.     Issues in The Study of The Qur`an, Kuala Lumpur: Ilmiah Publisher, 2002.

Watt, W. Montgomery.           What Is Islam, Beirut: Library of Lebanon, 1990.

Watt, W. Montgomery.           Muhammad: Prophet and The Statesman, Oxford:  Oxford University Press, 1948.

Watt,  W. Montgomery.          Muhammad at Mecca, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1988.




[1] Abdur Radi M. Abdul. Muhsin, Muhammad's Prophethood Reality or Myth, (Riyadh: International Islamic Publishing, 2008), 88
[2] Carole Hillenbrand. “Professor W. Montgomery Watt: Son of the Presbyterian Manse and Episcopal Priest Who Became a Leading Interpreter of Islam”. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/obituaries/professor-w-montgomery-watt-423394.html (accessed February 20, 2013).
[3] “William Montgomery Watt”, http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/46358.William_Montgomery_Watt (accessed February 20, 2013).
[4] Carole Hillenbrand. “Professor W. Montgomery Watt: Son of the Presbyterian Manse and Episcopal Priest Who Became a Leading Interpreter of Islam”. op.cit.
[5] R. Holloway. “William Montgomery Watt: A Christian scholar in search of Islamic understanding”. http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/2006/nov/14/guardianobituaries.highereducation (accessed February 20, 2013).
[6] Carole Hillenbrand, “Professor W. Montgomery Watt”, Edinburgh Middle East Report Online, Winter 2006
[7] Muhammad Mohar Ali, Sirat al-Nabi And The Orientalist, (Madinah: King Fahd Complex of Printing The Holy Quran, 1997), ix
[8]  A review on the book “Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman”. http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/81393.Muhammad (accessed February 20, 2013).
[9]  Israr Ahmad Khan, Towards Understanding the Mission of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. Unpublished manuscript, 56
[10] Muhammad Mohar Ali, Sirat al-Nabi, op.cit., 23-27
[11] Omar Jah, “Al Balagh” in Knowledge, Language, Thought & the Civilization of Islam ed. Wan Mohd Nor Wan Daud, 83 (Johor Bharu: UTM Press, 2010).
[12] W. Montgomery Watt, What Is Islam, (Beirut: Library of Lebanon, 1990), 23
[13] Ibid., 6.
[14] Adi Setia Mohd Dom, Worldview of Islam Academy: The Concept, Unpublished paperwork, 7.
[15] Ibid.
[16] Muhsin, Abdur Radi M. Abdul. Muhammad's Prophethood, op.cit., 20.
[17] Surah al-An’am (6): 143.
[18] Muhsin, Abdur Radi M. Abdul. Muhammad's Prophethood, op.cit., 22.
[19] Ibid. 23.
[20] Syed Muhammad Naquib al-Attas, Prolegomena to The Metaphysics of Islam: An Exposition of The Fundamental Elements of The Worldview of Islam, (Kuala Lumpur: ISTAC, 1995), 4.
[21] Israr Ahmad Khan, Qur`anic Studies: An Introduction, (Kuala Lumpur: Zaman Islam Media, 2000), 35-36.
[22] Ibid. 35
[23] Surah al-Maidah (5): 69.
[24] Syed Muhammad Naquib al-Attas, Prolegomena, op.cit., 6.
[25] Ibid.
[26] Israr Ahmad Khan, Towards Understanding the Mission, op.cit.42.
[27] Surah Ali-Imran (3): 164.
[28] W. Montgomery Watt, What Is Islam, op.cit., 223. See also W. Montgomery Watt, Muhammad: Prophet and The Statesman, (Oxford:  Oxford University Press, 1948), 19-20.
[29] Ibid, 223
[30] Thameem Ushama, Issues in The Study of The Qur`an, (Kuala Lumpur: Ilmiah Publisher, 2002), 71
[31] W. Montgomery Watt, Muhammad: Prophet and The Statesman, (Oxford:  Oxford University Press, 1948), 15
[32] Syed Muhammad Naquib al-Attas, Prolegomena, op.cit.,6
[33] Israr Ahmad Khan, Qur`anic Studies, op.cit, 16
[34] Ibid., 49
[35] W. Montgomery Watt, What Is Islam, op.cit., 13. See also 17.
[36] Ibid., 23.
[37] Ibid., 46.
[38] Ibid.
[39] Muhammad Mohar Ali, Sirat al-Nabi, op.cit. 216.
[40] Syed Muhammad Naquib al-Attas, Prolegomena, op.cit., 4.
[41] Ibid.
[42] Israr Ahmad Khan, Qur`anic Studies, op.cit, 49.
[43] Surah al-Baqarah(2): 135.
[44] Muhammad Mohar Ali, Sirat al-Nabi, op.cit. 454.
[45] Israr Ahmad Khan, Qur`anic Studies, op.cit, 35.
[46] Muhammad Mohar Ali, Sirat al-Nabi,  op.cit. 435.
[47] W. Montgomery Watt, Muhammad at Mecca, (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1988), 16.
[48] Surah al-Takwir (81): 19.
[49] Surah al-Qadr (97): 4, Surah al-Ma’arij (70): 4, Surah al-Naba’ (78): 38.
[50] Surah al-Syu’ara (26): 193.
[51] W. Montgomery Watt, What Is Islam, op.cit. 46.
[52] Ibid., 98.
[53] W. Montgomery Watt, What Is Islam, op.cit. 223. See also 42.
[54] W. Montgomery Watt, Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman, op.cit.  61.
[55] Surah al-Haqqah (69): 44-46
[56] Israr Ahmad Khan, Qur`anic Studies, op.cit, 50.
[57] Ibid., 51.

MKRdezign

{facebook#YOUR_SOCIAL_PROFILE_URL} {twitter#YOUR_SOCIAL_PROFILE_URL} {google-plus#YOUR_SOCIAL_PROFILE_URL} {pinterest#YOUR_SOCIAL_PROFILE_URL} {youtube#YOUR_SOCIAL_PROFILE_URL} {instagram#YOUR_SOCIAL_PROFILE_URL}

Borang Maklumat Hubungan

Nama

E-mel *

Mesej *

Copyright � 2011 peminggirkota. Dikuasakan oleh Blogger.
Javascript DisablePlease Enable Javascript To See All Widget